The Kugel Law Firm's Blog

Can Drivers Still Challenge the Alcotest 9510 in New Jersey DWI Cases?

Posted on November 18, 2026

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn

An Alcotest 9510 breath test result does not automatically lead to a DWI conviction in New Jersey. Testing errors, calibration problems, and improper procedures can raise questions about the accuracy of the reading. Although State v. Chun established standards for the older Alcotest 7110, the scientific reliability of the newer 9510 remains open to challenges in individual DWI cases.

At The Kugel Law Firm, New Jersey DWI defense lawyer Rachel Kugel defends drivers facing DWI charges involving Alcotest 9510 results. Our team reviews breath test records, testing procedures, and other evidence to identify potential grounds for challenging the results. We represent clients in Newark and throughout New Jersey, helping them understand their legal options and prepare their defense.

This guide explains how the Alcotest 9510 works, the legal requirements for admitting breath test evidence, common grounds for challenging results, and what happens when a reading is excluded. Call The Kugel Law Firm at (973) 854-0098 to discuss your case.

Can You Still Challenge the Alcotest 9510 in New Jersey?

Yes, Alcotest 9510 breath test results can still be challenged in New Jersey. Before admitting a reading into evidence, the court must determine whether the State has established that the device was functioning properly and the test was administered correctly. Calibration problems, operator certification issues, and procedural errors can provide grounds for excluding the result.

Even if the breath-test result is excluded, the DWI charge is not automatically dismissed. Without other admissible BAC evidence, the State cannot establish a per se DWI violation through chemical testing. However, prosecutors can still pursue an impairment-based charge using the officer’s observations, driving behavior, and field sobriety evidence. The outcome depends on the remaining evidence.

What Is the Alcotest 9510 and How Does It Differ From the 7110?

The Alcotest 9510 is a newer breath testing instrument manufactured by Draeger that has replaced the Alcotest 7110 MKIII-C in many New Jersey police departments. While both devices use dual infrared (IR) and electrochemical (fuel cell) sensors, they differ in design, software, and testing procedures. The Alcotest 9510 utilizes ethanol dry-gas standards for routine control checks, whereas the older 7110 relied on wet-bath simulator solution testing.

The Alcotest 9510 measures alcohol concentration through both sensors during each breath sample, producing four separate analytical readings across two breath samples. In June 2024, the New Jersey Division of Criminal Justice issued interim instructions requiring breath test operators to verify these readings using an approved Alcotest calculator. Operators were directed to disregard the machine-calculated average and instead use the lowest qualifying value for prosecution until required firmware updates were installed. Because of these rules, the device’s firmware version and the specific testing protocol used during an arrest are critical evidence.

These technical differences also affect how courts view the device. In State v. Chun, the New Jersey Supreme Court established the scientific reliability of the older Alcotest 7110, but that ruling does not automatically apply to the 9510. The Supreme Court previously stayed certain Alcotest 9510 DWI cases in May 2023 while reviewing its reliability. On December 19, 2025, the Court dismissed the lead case, State v. Cunningham, after the defendant withdrew the challenge. Because the Court dismissed the appeal without ruling on the technical merits, it never issued a binding decision declaring the Alcotest 9510 scientifically reliable.

As a result, defendants can still challenge Alcotest 9510 results in individual DWI cases. These challenges can also rely on the scientific evidence framework adopted in State v. Olenowski, 253 N.J. 133 (2023), which considers factors such as testing methods, error rates, validation procedures, and other evidence bearing on the instrument’s reliability.

What Are the Grounds for Challenging Alcotest 9510 Results?

Alcotest 9510 results can be challenged based on errors involving operator certification, the required observation period, calibration, software, or medical conditions that affect breath samples. The defense examines testing records, video footage, and other available evidence to determine whether these issues affected the accuracy or admissibility of the result.

Potential Ground for Challenge What the Defense Looks For Records Typically Reviewed
Observation period Interruptions in the 20-minute observation period or circumstances that prevented an officer from detecting events affecting the breath sample AIR timestamps, station video, body camera footage
Operator certification Expired or missing certification at the time of testing Operator certification records
Calibration and repair history Missed calibration dates, failed control tests, or undocumented repairs Calibration reports, repair logs, control test results
Software and data records Error messages, aborted tests, or inconsistencies in recorded readings Device data downloads, AIR printouts
Medical or mouth alcohol factors Reflux, belching, vomiting, or dental appliances that retain alcohol Medical records, dental records, observation period video

How Do Operator and Observation Period Errors Affect a Test?

New Jersey requires a 20-minute observation period before breath testing to reduce the risk of mouth alcohol affecting the result. During this time, an officer must continuously monitor the driver for events such as drinking, vomiting, or regurgitation that could contaminate the breath sample. The observing officer does not have to be the Alcotest operator, but an event that compromises the sample requires the observation period to restart.

Operator qualifications and testing procedures are equally important. The defense examines whether the officer held the required Alcotest 9510 certification and followed the proper testing sequence. Comparing the Alcohol Influence Report (AIR) timestamps with station video and body camera footage can reveal gaps in observation or errors in administering the test. These findings can support a challenge to the breath test result.

How Do Maintenance and Calibration Records Affect a Test?

The Alcotest 9510 requires periodic certification and testing to confirm that it operates correctly. Certification reports, control-test results, and maintenance records help establish whether the instrument was functioning properly when the driver’s breath samples were collected. Missing documentation, failed tests, or unresolved equipment problems can raise questions about the reliability of the reading.

The importance of these procedures was demonstrated in State v. Cassidy, 235 N.J. 482 (2018), when the New Jersey Supreme Court ruled certain Alcotest 7110 results inadmissible because a required calibration procedure involving a NIST-traceable thermometer had not been followed. Although the case involved the older 7110 and affected more than 20,000 breath tests, it illustrates why proper certification and compliance with testing requirements matter when challenging breath test evidence.

Can Medical Conditions or Mouth Alcohol Affect a Result?

Yes. Conditions such as gastroesophageal reflux, along with regurgitation or recent vomiting, can introduce alcohol into the mouth and affect a breath test reading. Dental appliances that retain alcohol can also interfere with the sample. However, the presence of a medical condition alone does not establish that the result is inaccurate.

To evaluate these factors, the defense reviews medical and dental records alongside available video footage from the observation period. Evidence connecting a specific condition or incident to an unreliable reading can support a request to exclude the result or challenge its weight in court.

New Jersey DWI Defense Attorney – The Kugel Law Firm

Rachel Kugel, Esq.

Rachel Kugel is a New Jersey DWI defense attorney with over 20 years of experience representing individuals charged with driving under the influence of alcohol or drugs in New York and New Jersey. She focuses her practice on DWI defense and is a member of the National College for DUI Defense and the DUI Defense Lawyers Association.

Throughout her career, Rachel has been invited to speak on DWI defense and the business of law by the New Jersey State Bar Association, Garden State CLE, and Avvo Lawyernomics. Her involvement in these professional organizations and speaking engagements reflects her commitment to staying informed about developments in DWI law and defense strategies.

How Does an Alcotest Challenge Work in New Jersey Court?

Challenging an Alcotest 9510 result begins with reviewing the evidence and identifying errors that affect its admissibility. New Jersey DWI cases are heard in municipal court before a judge rather than a jury. Depending on the issues identified, the defense can raise objections to the breath test evidence or request a hearing to determine whether the result can be admitted.

Under New Jersey Court Rule 7:7-7, the defense is entitled to complete discovery from the municipal prosecutor, including the AIR printout, calibration certifications, solution and gas change reports, operator credentials, digital data downloads, and video recordings.

The legal procedure depends on the grounds for the challenge. Rule 7:5-2 governs motions to suppress evidence resulting from unlawful stops, searches, or seizures. Substantive disputes regarding the machine’s scientific reliability, calibration integrity, or test administration are raised as evidentiary objections before or during trial.

What Happens If the Breath Test Result Is Excluded?

Excluding an Alcotest 9510 result does not automatically dismiss a New Jersey DWI charge. Prosecutors can still pursue a conviction under N.J.S.A. 39:4-50(a) by relying on evidence of impairment rather than a blood alcohol concentration (BAC) reading. This includes the officer’s observations of the driver’s behavior, speech, appearance, and performance on field sobriety tests.

The defense can challenge this evidence by comparing police reports with available video footage, reviewing how field sobriety tests were administered, and identifying alternative explanations for the officer’s observations. Without an admissible breath test result, the strength of the remaining evidence becomes central to the case.

If the evidence supports an impairment-based charge, prosecutors can proceed to trial or consider a resolution permitted under New Jersey law. If the remaining evidence is insufficient, the charge can be dismissed. The outcome depends on the specific facts and evidence presented.

How Does a Breath Reading Affect New Jersey DWI Penalties?

Blood alcohol concentration (BAC) affects the penalties for a New Jersey DWI conviction under N.J.S.A. 39:4-50(a)(1). Different BAC levels carry different license and ignition interlock requirements, so even a small difference in an Alcotest reading can affect the penalties a driver faces.

BAC Tier First-Offense License and Interlock Consequences
0.08% to less than 0.10% License forfeiture until an ignition interlock device is installed, followed by a 3-month interlock requirement
0.10% to less than 0.15% License forfeiture until an ignition interlock device is installed, with an interlock requirement of 7 months to 1 year
0.15% or higher Three months of license forfeiture following interlock installation, with the device required during forfeiture and for 12 to 15 months after license restoration

In addition to these penalties, a first or second DWI conviction carries a Motor Vehicle Commission (MVC) surcharge of $1,000 per year for three years. Drivers must also attend the Intoxicated Driver Resource Center (IDRC) for 12 to 48 hours.

Because the penalties depend on BAC levels, errors involving calibration, testing procedures, or mouth alcohol can affect which penalty tier applies. A reading near a threshold, such as 0.099% compared with 0.100%, makes the accuracy of the Alcotest result particularly important.

What Should You Do After Taking the Alcotest Following a DWI Arrest?

After taking an Alcotest 9510 during a DWI investigation, preserving relevant documents and recording details about the testing process can help identify errors affecting the result. The following steps can help protect your defense:

  • Keep your paperwork: Save your summons, Alcohol Influence Report (AIR), and other documents related to the arrest. If you did not receive the AIR, request a copy.
  • Record what happened: Write down the timeline of the traffic stop and breath test, including whether you belched, vomited, or had anything in your mouth before testing.
  • Gather medical and dental records: Keep records of conditions such as acid reflux or dental work that could affect the breath sample.
  • Document independent testing: Note whether you requested or obtained an independent chemical test. Under N.J.S.A. 39:4-50.2, drivers who submit to police-administered breath testing have the right to seek independent testing.
  • Speak with an attorney promptly: A New Jersey DWI lawyer can review the testing procedures, request relevant records, and identify grounds for challenging the result before applicable court deadlines.

Choosing not to obtain an independent test does not prevent you from challenging the Alcotest reading. The defense can still examine the instrument’s condition, operator certification, and testing procedures to determine whether the State has established the requirements for admitting the result.

Speak With a New Jersey DWI Defense Attorney

An Alcotest 9510 result can play a significant role in a New Jersey DWI case, but errors in calibration, operator certification, or testing procedures can provide grounds for challenging its admissibility. A careful review of the breath test evidence can help identify issues that affect the accuracy and reliability of the reading.

At The Kugel Law Firm, New Jersey DWI defense lawyer Rachel Kugel represents drivers facing charges involving Alcotest 9510 results. Our team examines testing records, identifies potential procedural errors, and challenges questionable evidence in court. We handle DWI cases in Newark Municipal Court and throughout Essex, Hudson, Union, and Bergen counties.

If you are facing a DWI charge involving an Alcotest 9510 result, call The Kugel Law Firm at (973) 854-0098 to schedule a free consultation. Our office is located at 1 Gateway Center, Suite 2600, Newark, NJ 07102, and we represent clients throughout New Jersey.

Frequently Asked Questions About Alcotest 9510 Challenges

Is the Alcotest 9510 the Same Device as the Alcotest 7110 MKIII-C?

No. The Alcotest 9510 is a newer Draeger breath testing instrument that has replaced the 7110 MKIII-C in many New Jersey police departments. Although both devices use two breath samples, they differ in their testing procedures, software, and reporting methods. These differences are important when evaluating the accuracy and admissibility of breath test results.

Can a Breath Test Result Above 0.08% Be Thrown Out in New Jersey?

Yes. A breath test result above 0.08% can be excluded if the State fails to establish the required foundation for its admission. Problems involving calibration, operator certification, the 20-minute observation period, or mouth alcohol can provide grounds for challenging the reading.

When Should You Challenge an Alcotest 9510 Result?

Alcotest 9510 results should be challenged as early as possible to allow time for reviewing evidence and meeting court deadlines. Under New Jersey Court Rule 7:5-2, motions involving evidence obtained through an unlawful search or seizure must be raised before trial. Challenges involving scientific reliability or improper testing procedures follow the applicable evidentiary procedures.

Can the State Still Convict Me if the Breath Test Is Excluded?

Yes. Prosecutors can still pursue a DWI conviction under N.J.S.A. 39:4-50(a) using evidence of impairment, including driving behavior, the officer’s observations, and field sobriety test results. The outcome depends on whether the remaining evidence establishes the offense.

Does Skipping an Independent Test Prevent Me From Challenging the Alcotest?

No. Under New Jersey law, drivers who undergo police-administered breath testing have the right to seek independent chemical testing. Even without a separate test, the defense can challenge the Alcotest result by examining the instrument’s condition, operator certification, and compliance with required testing procedures.

What Is the Alcohol Influence Report, and Why Does It Matter?

The Alcohol Influence Report (AIR) is a record generated by the Alcotest that contains breath test readings, sample times, and information about the operator and instrument. The defense uses this report alongside calibration records, device data, and available video footage to identify errors or inconsistencies that affect the result.

Schedule a Free Consultation